A strike is better than a spare. A strike earns a bonus of your next two balls, while a spare earns a bonus of only your next one ball, so a strike frame can be worth up to 30 pins and a spare frame up to 20.
That said, the bigger difference in most bowlers’ scores isn’t strikes versus spares — it’s spares versus open frames. Here’s how the scoring works and why coaches spend so much time on the second ball.
How strikes and spares are scored
A game has ten frames. In each of the first nine frames you get up to two balls to knock down all ten pins.
- Strike (X): all ten pins on the first ball. The frame scores 10 plus the pins from your next two balls.
- Spare (/): all ten pins using both balls. The frame scores 10 plus the pins from your next one ball.
- Open frame: pins left standing after two balls. The frame scores only the pins you knocked down, with no bonus.
So a strike is worth anywhere from 10 to 30 for that frame, and a spare from 10 to 20, depending on what comes next.
A frame-by-frame comparison
Here are two bowlers whose next frame is identical — a 7 on the first ball, then 2 more for an open 9.
| Frame 1 | Frame 2 | Frame 1 score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bowler A | Strike | 7, 2 | 10 + 7 + 2 = 19 |
| Bowler B | 8, then spare | 7, 2 | 10 + 7 = 17 |
The strike is worth 2 more here. Now suppose the next frames are strikes:
| Frame 1 | Frames 2 and 3 | Frame 1 score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bowler A | Strike | Strike, strike | 10 + 10 + 10 = 30 |
| Bowler B | 8, then spare | Strike, strike | 10 + 10 = 20 |
When strikes come in a row, the gap widens quickly. That’s why strings of strikes, like a turkey (three in a row), push scores up so fast, and why a perfect game of twelve straight strikes reaches 300.
Why spares matter more than they look
What a missed spare costs
Compare a spare with an open frame, assuming the same first ball:
| Frame 1 | Next ball | Frame 1 score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spare | 9, then spare | 8 | 10 + 8 = 18 |
| Missed spare | 9, then miss | 8 | 9 + 0 = 9 |
Missing that single pin cost 9 pins. If the frame before was a strike, the miss costs one more pin, because the strike’s bonus also counted that second ball. Depending on the next ball, a missed single-pin spare usually costs somewhere around 8 to 11 pins.
Strikes depend partly on things you don’t fully control: pin carry, lane conditions and small differences in where the ball enters the pocket. Most single-pin spares, by contrast, are very makeable with a good system. For many bowlers, converting more spares is the quickest way to raise an average.
Clean games: what all-spare scoring looks like
A “clean game” means no open frames. A few benchmark games show how much spares alone can carry you:
- Nine on every first ball, spare every frame (and nine on the fill ball): each frame scores 19, for a 190 game — without a single strike.
- Eight on every first ball, spare every frame (and eight on the fill ball): each frame scores 18, for a 180 game.
- Alternating strikes and spares every frame: every frame scores 20, for a 200 game, often called a Dutch 200.
- All strikes: 300.
So a bowler who never strikes but never misses a spare can score in the 170s to 190 range, depending on first-ball counts. Add a few strikes and that clean game moves past 200. Meanwhile, a bowler who strikes often but leaves several open frames can easily score lower.
Strikes vs spares in the 10th frame
The 10th frame works a little differently, but the same principle applies:
- Strike on the first ball: you get two more balls. The frame can be worth up to 30.
- Spare: you get one more ball (the fill ball). The frame can be worth up to 20.
- Open frame: no extra balls.
A spare in the 10th still gives you a bonus ball, so finishing clean matters even in the last frame.
So what should you practice?
Both — but in most cases, spares first. Strikes produce the biggest single frames, but spares protect your score from the costly open frames that pull averages down. A practical order for many bowlers is:
- Make single pins routine, especially the corner pins. Our guides on the 10 pin and the 7 pin cover the most-missed ones.
- Use a spare system so every leave has a plan. Start with our guide to spare alignment and the 3-6-9 system.
- Practice spares on purpose, not just when they happen. Our spare drills show how to do this on a full rack.
- Then work on your strike ball to add more of those 20- and 30-pin frames.
The short answer stays the same: a strike is worth more. But a game without open frames is usually the foundation of a good score.