Scoring and Formats

Is 9 pin bowling still illegal?

No, nine-pin bowling isn't illegal today. Here's where the 19th-century ban story comes from, what's myth, Texas's exception and where ninepins is played now.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Where the “illegal” idea comes from
  3. Did the ban really create ten-pin bowling?
  4. Texas: taxed, not banned
  5. Are any old nine-pin laws still on the books?
  6. Where nine-pin is played today
  7. Gambling is a separate question

The short answer

No. Nine-pin bowling isn’t illegal in the places where it’s played today. It’s an organized, governed sport across much of central and eastern Europe, and a small version of it is still bowled in clubs in Texas.

The question comes from a well-known piece of bowling history: in the 1800s, some American states and cities restricted or banned nine-pin alleys, and the story goes that bowlers added a tenth pin to get around the law. That story is where the “is it still illegal?” question comes from.

Where the “illegal” idea comes from

In the first half of the 19th century, nine-pin bowling was a popular pastime in parts of the United States, often in taverns and alleys where betting was common. Some states and cities passed laws aimed at ninepin alleys, usually because of concerns about gambling, drinking and idleness rather than the game itself.

Accounts of exactly which places passed these laws, and when, vary between sources. Connecticut is the state most often named, with dates in the late 1830s or early 1840s, and New York and Massachusetts are sometimes mentioned too. Because the retellings differ, it’s best to treat specific dates in popular histories with some caution.

Did the ban really create ten-pin bowling?

The popular version says that bowlers simply added a tenth pin, set the pins in a triangle, and kept bowling legally because the law only named “nine pins.” It’s a good story, and it’s possible that this loophole played some role in some places.

But ten-pin bowling didn’t come out of nowhere. Games with ten pins in a triangle were known before the American bans, and the shift from nine to ten pins in the US likely had several causes. Most bowling historians present the loophole story as part of the picture, not the whole explanation.

Texas: taxed, not banned

Texas took a different route. In 1837, the Congress of the Republic of Texas chose to tax ninepin alleys rather than ban them. Nine-pin remained popular in German communities in central Texas well into the 20th century, and a small number of clubs still bowl it today, using ten-pin lanes and balls with nine pins set by hand. Our guide to nine-pin bowling equipment and setup explains how the Texas game works.

Are any old nine-pin laws still on the books?

This comes up often in lists of strange old laws. We aren’t aware of any current law that is enforced against nine-pin bowling as a game, and modern bowling centers that offer nine-pin or similar games operate openly.

Whether every 19th-century statute was formally repealed is harder to say, because old laws were often replaced, folded into broader gambling statutes or simply left unused. If you need a definite answer for a specific state or city, for example because you’re planning to open a venue, check with a local attorney or the relevant licensing authority.

Where nine-pin is played today

  • Europe: nine-pin is a serious sport with national federations, leagues and world championships organized under the World Ninepin Bowling Association. It’s especially strong in Germany, Austria, Czechia, Slovakia, Hungary, Croatia, Slovenia and Serbia.
  • Texas: a handful of clubs in communities with German heritage keep the tradition going.
  • Elsewhere: pockets of nine-pin exist where German-speaking immigrants settled, such as South Australia’s Barossa Valley.

Gambling is a separate question

The old bans were mostly about betting. Today, playing nine-pin, ten-pin or any other bowling game is legal in itself, but wagering on it can be a different matter. Gambling laws vary widely between countries, states and cities.

That’s also true of common league side games. If you’re curious how those work, see our explainer on bowling brackets and sidepots, which includes a note on local rules. This article isn’t legal advice; for specific situations, check local law.

The complete guide to scoring and formats

How Bowling Scoring Works: Frames, Strikes and Spares
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →